'Iron Man' #178 Part 2

'Struggle!'

Today's Iron Man story represents the darker side of Assistant Editors' Month. As we saw in the earlier entry that covered 'Incredible Hulk' #291, not every AEM story was a laugh riot.
We pick up from where we left off in the last post: Assistant Editor Mike Carlin's laughter over part 1 turns into tears over the second story of #178:


'Struggle!' was written by Denny O'Neil, drawn by Luke McDonnell and inked by Steve Mitchell. Once again, we get a different origin banner on the splash page, which nicely sets up the story.
It begins with a hung-over, homeless Tony Stark wandering aimlessly through New York on a hot summer day.


That's some nice descriptive text from O'Neil, I can taste copper in my mouth after reading it!

A man throws Stark a quarter, his companion says it's wrong to give their "hard-earned money away to bums!". Stark protests, saying he's no bum, but a millionaire and a superhero.


Two NYPD officers (let's call them "younger cop" and "older cop", they're never named) notice the slumped over figure of Stark and confront him. He denies being a "drunk", saying he just got out of detox for a "nervous condition". Stark's refusal to admit he has an alcohol problem disgusts younger cop and older cop says Stark is "hopeless".

I have to say that this is one of the lowest points I've seen for any comic book character. This is right up there with Spider-Man after the death of Gwen Stacy.

Younger cop makes a bet with Stark. He'll give him $50 if he can stay sober until midnight. Stark accepts and walks away. We learn that younger cop's father was an alcoholic. He made the bet with Stark knowing that staying sober will be a painful experience.

Stark spends his last quarter on a phone call to Jim Rhodes, who isn't home. Morely Irwin (a former Stark employee) answers the phone, but Stark won't talk to him.

Stark remembers another former employee named Vic Martinelli lives nearby and heads for his apartment. He passes a bar on the way, fixating on the "open" sign on the door.
Vic lends him $20, but Stark disappointed that he hasn't quit his job even though Obadiah Stane now runs the company. He tells Stark he can't expect loyalty anymore because "you drank it away." Vic regrets yelling at Stark, but the damage is done. Stark passes a bar and hears two men talk about getting "knee-walkin' drunk". He contemplates joining them for a drink, but changes his mind.

Instead, Stark enters the bar and uses the pay phone to call his former secretary Bambi Arbogast. She asks if he's been drinking and recommends Alcoholics Anonymous for Stark. He won't do it, still insisting he's not an alcoholic.
Stark is asked to leave the bar if he isn't drinking. Back on the streets, he encounters a man named Ozzie Sanborn, who recognizes Stark from detox. Ozzie says that his liver and kidneys will stop working if he keeps drinking, but his alcoholism is so intense that he doesn't care.
Ozzie's "girlfriend" Gretl(who Ozzie "just met") offers to buy drinks for everyone, Stark turns them down, which angers Ozzie. Left alone again, Stark wonders why he didn't take them up on the drink, as his withdrawal symptoms worsen and he doubles over in pain on a bench.
Stark falls asleep on the bench and is woken up by a policeman who tells him "it's almost midnight". Stark goes to meet younger cop and collect his $50. He says "in five minutes, I'll be drinking again" and thanks the officer for showing him that he is indeed an alcoholic. Younger cop is glad Stark has admitted his addiction, and cries, telling him "That's the reason I did it...You see, my old man was a drunk." The end.

Great story. Tony Stark(and Iron Man,for that matter) was never my favorite character, but I sympathized with him in this story. When I first read this, my image of alcoholics came from "very special episodes" of sitcoms. Ozzie's line about drinking even though he knows it will kill him is still chilling all these years later. O'Neil, McDonnell and Mitchell did a great job here of conveying the pain and emptiness of addiction as well as the disdain some people have for "drunks".

Next:
Ann Nocenti helps Roger Stern find creative inspiration!

'Iron Man' #178 Part 1

'Once An Avenger, Always An Avenger!'


Welcome back to 'Assistant Editors' Month', today we look at an "Iron Man" story unlike any other.

Some context:

During this era, ‘Iron Man’ was written by Denny O’Neil. Tony Stark had a relapse of his alcoholism, which cost him control of his company Stark International and forced him to give up his Iron Man armor. Obadiah Stane took over the company(renaming it ‘Stane International’) and James Rhodes(Stark’s Chief Of Security) became the new Iron Man. Stark eventually defeated Stane and regained control of his company in 'Iron Man' #200.

The Assistant Editor for this issue was Mike Carlin, we “met” him in an earlier AEM post. Let's recap 'Iron Man' #178, starting with the cover:

In the corner box, Iron Man is turning his back on the issue, and we get the checkerboards and ‘MC’ logo parodying DC’s logo of the 60s again. A disheveled Stark is walking the streets while a boy tears down & defaces posters of Iron Man. Also, if you look closely at the graffiti, you’ll see “Luke + Stevie was here”.

The cover was drawn by Luke McDonnell and inked by Steve Mitchell, that’s a nice way to “sign” the cover.

Instead of the usual "origin" recap normally found atop the splash page, we get an explanation for Editor Mark Gruenwald's "absence":

'Once An Avenger, Always An Avenger' was written by Bob Harras with art by the aforementioned McDonnell and Mitchell.

We open on a kid contemplating vandalism, but he is stopped by the Avengers…or more accurately, a group of young children in homemade “Avengers” costumes. We learn the would-be vandal is Blackie Donovan and the Kostumed Kiddies have pledged to watch the car while its owner is hospitalized.

Donovan promises them they will pay for their interference, while he is taken home by Officer Kelly, the neighborhood beat cop. He wishes Donovan would act more like the "Avenger" kids and we get the impression this isn't the first time Donovan has been caught being a bad boy.

I've always thought that Officer Kelly looked like the Avengers long-time Government Liaison Henry Peter Gyrich. I wonder if that was intentional?

Just like the “real” Avengers, the kids hold a weekly membership meeting, “Iron Man”, whose real name is Mikey, is commended for catching Donovan, but then gets some bad news. In the (then) current issues of ‘The Avengers’, Iron Man had recently left the team, therefore this Iron Man must leave their team.

This part of the story really hit home for me. When I was a kid, I had a friend who always insisted on strict adherence to comic book "continuity" when we played "superheroes". For instance, when we played with Mego dolls, we couldn't use the Joker because Joker was "dead" at the time.

Mikey begs the team to let him stay, but their decision is final.

Mikey wanders the streets, dejected, and discards his “helmet”. Unbeknownst to him, it’s picked up by a shadowy figure, who absconds with it.

On the following day, Iron Man goes on a bullying rampage, breaking toys, stealing bikes and taking lunch money.

When the Avengers go out on a neighborhood "patrol", all the children run away from them in fear.

They’re confused, until Officer Kelly tells them of Iron Man’s recent shenanigans. The Avengers are determined to get to the bottom of this!

Meanwhile, we catch up with Mikey, who just like his hero Iron Man, is “hitting the bottle”…the Coke bottle, that is.

Mikey’s former teammates chide him for Iron Man’s behavior, he pleads innocent and decides to clear his name, Iron Man-style! We get a nice "montage" of Mikey modifying a suit of armor.

A day later, we find Iron Man(literally) taking candy from a baby! Suddenly, the Avengers show up, followed by another Iron Man...on roller skates!

Before anyone has a chance to yell "Shoot Us both,Spock!", the battle is over! The bogus Iron Man is unmasked and revealed to be none other than...Blackie Donovan! . Officer Kelly shows up and tells Donovan he's taking him home to face his mother's punishment. The Avengers apologize and offer Avengers membership to Mikey. He accepts their apology, rejoins the team, and our story ends with the Avengers traditional battle cry!

The end.

Next up, we get a one-page strip written, drawn and "starring" Mike Carlin:


He's laughing over the previous tale about the kids, which prompts him to go on a tangent about 'Little Rascals' short films. But then he remembers how sad the issue's next story is and fights back tears.

And that's where I'll leave you, next time we'll cover Part 2 of this issue.

Thank you Bob Harass, Luke McDonnell,Steve Mitchell and Mike Carlin for another fun AEM story!

J.A.